Best Pizza Varieties to Try for a Family Dinner
Planning a family dinner that pleases everyone can feel like solving a puzzle especially when you have picky little eaters on one end and adventurous foodies on the other. Luckily, pizza is the great equalizer. With the right mix of varieties, pizza night can become everyone’s favourite tradition.
Here’s a guide to the best pizza varieties to try for your next family dinner, along with tips on how to mix and match for a perfect spread.
1. Classic Cheese Pizza The Ultimate Crowd-Pleaser
When in doubt, start with cheese. A well-made classic cheese pizza with a crispy yet chewy crust, bright tomato sauce, and gooey melted mozzarella is far from boring. It’s the anchor of any multi-pizza order and gives picky eaters a safe, familiar option while you get adventurous with the second pie.
Pro tip: Opt for a blend of mozzarella and provolone for a deeper, richer flavour without straying too far from the classic.
Try our Classic Cheese Pizza it’s on our full menu alongside a wide range of classic and craft options perfect for every family member.”
2. Pepperoni Pizza The Easy, Always-Welcome Upgrade
If cheese is the baseline, pepperoni is the no-brainer upgrade. It adds a satisfying, slightly spicy kick without intimidating cautious eaters. Pepperoni pizzas are typically the first to disappear at any family gathering, making them a smart addition to any two-pizza order.
Family tip: Try cupping pepperoni (the kind with curled edges) for crispy, flavour-packed bites that kids absolutely love.
3. Margherita Pizza Fresh, Simple, and Timeless
For families who appreciate fresh, clean flavours, Margherita pizza is a beautiful choice. The combination of San Marzano tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, and fragrant basil leaves feels elegant yet approachable. It’s a wonderful way to introduce younger family members to “grown-up” flavours without overwhelming them.
Did you know? The Margherita pizza was created in 1889 in honour of Queen Margherita of Italy making it one of the most iconic pies in history.
4. Grandma Pie Special Enough for Family Dinner
When you want pizza night to feel a little more special, a Grandma pie delivers. Baked in an oiled rectangular pan, it features a thick, crispy-bottomed crust, chunky tomato sauce spread on top of the cheese, and a pillowy interior. Its square slices make portioning and sharing a breeze perfect for a family table.
Serving idea: Pair Grandma pie with a simple Caesar salad for a complete, satisfying family meal.
5. Sicilian Pizza — Thick, Hearty, and Easy to Share
Similar in spirit to the Grandma pie, Sicilian pizza is known for its thick, airy rectangular crust and generous toppings. It’s filling, easy to slice into generous portions, and holds up well even when it cools down a bit which is great when the family table gets a little chaotic.
Fun fact: Traditional Sicilian pizza (sfincione) often features onions, anchovies, and breadcrumbs though American-style versions have evolved significantly.
6. Specialty & Comfort Food Pizzas — For the Adventurous Family
If your family is open to getting creative, specialty pizzas open up a whole world of delicious possibilities. Some crowd-favourite options to try:
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza — Tangy buffalo sauce, grilled chicken, and a drizzle of ranch. A game-night favourite.
- Chicken Parmesan Pizza — All the comfort of chicken parm, reimagined on a pizza crust.
- White Pizza with Sautéed Veggies — A garlic-olive oil base with roasted vegetables, perfect for veggie-loving families.
- Lasagna Pizza — Layers of ricotta, meat sauce, and mozzarella on a pizza crust. Pure comfort food.
- Chimichurri Pizza — For families who love bold, herbaceous flavours.
The Perfect Family Pizza Night Strategy
Not sure how many pizzas to order or make? Here’s a simple formula that works every time:
Order one classic + one specialty. The classic (cheese or pepperoni) keeps everyone happy, while the specialty pie adds excitement and variety for those willing to explore.
If you’re making pizza at home, set up a pizza topping bar lay out different sauces, cheeses, and toppings and let everyone build their own mini pizza. It’s fun, interactive, and guarantees no complaints about toppings.
Find a Curry Pizza House near you across California, Texas, Nevada, Virginia, and more.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re ordering from your favourite pizzeria or rolling out dough in your own kitchen, the best pizza for a family dinner is one that brings everyone together. Start with a reliable classic, add one adventurous option, and let the conversation (and the slices) flow freely.
At Curry Pizza House®, our menu was born from a love of family pizza nights as first-generation Indian Americans, Friday pizza nights were a cherished tradition that inspired everything we do.
The perfect family pizza night isn’t just about the food it’s about the experience. And with so many incredible varieties to choose from, you really can’t go wrong
Want to make family pizza night even better? Check out our latest coupons and deals before you order.
